The duo performed “Nothing Compares 2 U,” a song originally written by Prince in 1985 and later popularized by O’Connor when she recorded it for her 1990 album, I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got.
However, their rendition of the song garnered mixed reactions from viewers, with many expressing disappointment.
Several Facebook users shared their opinions on the performance, with many criticizing Cyrus’ vocals. One user wrote, “That was painful to watch. Such an amazing song and this was a disrespect to Sinead.”
Another comment described it as “One of the evening’s low points.” Some viewers took issue with Cyrus’ singing, with one stating, “Miley has such a mediocre voice.” Another added, “Wish it was only Brittany. Miley should have just left it alone [sic].”
Others were more direct in their criticism. One person commented, “Absolutely ruined the song. It was tragic.” Another expressed disappointment, “Miley Cyrus… why?”
While some fans acknowledged their appreciation for Cyrus as an artist, they felt the performance did not suit her voice.
One user shared, “I love Miley but not for that song. Howard should have done it. I only really like Sinead and Price versions. I love the song [sic].”
Others noted issues with the arrangement, with one stating, “I love me some Miley but this was not her best vocal. Thank goodness for Britany. The arrangement was weird [sic].”
Some were particularly critical of Cyrus’ live singing ability. One user wrote, “Miley, like always, was HORRIBLE live. She sang flat, monotone and showed that she is extremely limited in her vocal range. Only mindless fanbois/girls will enjoy it. Brittany sang her off the stage [sic].”
While the performance was intended as a tribute to O’Connor, it ultimately drew sharp reactions from viewers. Despite differing opinions on the execution, the moment served as a reminder of the impact “Nothing Compares 2 U” has had over the years.
